I recently bought a second hand car, and was struck by an unusual phenomenon. Why do certain second hand asset purchases (like a car) come with a safety report yet other second hand asset purchases (houses) do not? Why aren’t we as concerned about safety in the home as we are about safety in a car?
UK law doesn’t require any safety report in a second hand car purchase, and yet the market has evolved to offer it (dealerships offer a mechanics report, driving organisations such as the AA offer to “look under the bonnet” before you buy the car etc). A house purchase typically involves a much larger sum of money than a car, and yet something in the market means that such a service is not offered. Why, when there is more money at stake buying houses, are we prepared to accept greater risk?
As an electrical contractor specialising in safety inspection, I was impressed that the second hand car sales process included a mechanic’s report to show that the car had been tested and inspected. It was reassuring. But it made me think how comparatively few calls we get for our pre-purchase house inspections. I know from experience that many “second hand” houses in my area are in an appalling electrical condition. If a second hand car had as many faults, it would be condemned. So why do we turn a blind eye to such danger in houses?
Despite the comparatively strong safety record of electricity, electrical fault is still the second most common cause of fire (ROSPA). The materials used in electrical installations deteriorate over time, just like car parts. Electrical safety technology evolves just as fast as technology in auto-manufacture. Inheriting poor quality DIY is also a major threat. Significantly, the costs of electrical failure far outweigh the costs of a precautionary report.
UK consumers are, typically, unaware of the benefits of a pre-purchase electrical safety report because of habit and tradition. In addition, market forces often result in people being too frightened of “losing” a dream house in a competitive situation to worry about safety precautions. However, a “cooling” market might just be the right time for the “market” to discover the benefits of a pre-purchase inspection.
Ultimately the benefits of a pre-purchase electrical safety inspection are peace of mind, time and cost savings (potentially for both parties if a sale completes without delay) and the removal of moral hazard (how should society treat the DIY-er whose botched job results in death at a later date?)
Recently the Government has tried to incorporate some element of electrical safety inspection in the HIP pack, but were dissuaded by the property industry complaints of stealth taxation! Even though companies like mine would have benefited from this, I agree that the solution is not to make another law.
Currently the state of domestic electrical safety in Britain’s second hand houses is poor, and this “costs” the Government and the Insurance Industry. It also costs lives. For this situation to improve, buyers and sellers (and estate agents!!) must start to consider an electrical safety report as they might consider a new kitchen or a lick of paint. In other words something that can make a sale “happen”. Full disclosure would move a market faster than any law, and it would also save society a considerable cost.